Is Your Property Manager Proactive or Reactive? How to Tell (Before It’s Too Late)
- Lee Doherty
- Jun 7
- 5 min read
Updated: Nov 11
Is Your Property Manager Proactive or Reactive? How to Tell the Difference
Is your property manager proactive or reactive? Understanding this difference can dramatically impact your investment. Discover expert tips, real examples, and essential questions that every landlord should ask.
Let’s Face It
Not all property managers are created equal. Some tackle issues before you even know they exist while others only act when something breaks. Knowing whether your property manager is proactive or reactive can mean the difference between a thriving investment and a string of headaches.
Why Does Proactivity in Property Management Matter?
Managing a property is more than just collecting rent and fixing things when they break. In today’s rental market, being proactive is essential. This approach saves money, time, and—let’s be honest—a whole lot of sanity.
Reduces costly repairs: Catching small issues early prevents expensive disasters.
Keeps tenants happy: Happy tenants are likely to stay longer, reducing vacancy.
Protects your asset: Regular maintenance preserves property value.
Ensures legal compliance: Staying ahead of legislation avoids nasty surprises.
If your property manager is asleep at the wheel, you may face serious issues down the line. However, with a proactive manager, problems are often solved before you even realize they existed.
Key Signs to Look For
It’s easy for a manager to claim they’re proactive, but actions speak louder than words. Here’s how to separate the go-getters from the wait-and-seers:
Communication: Are You In the Loop?
Proactive Managers
Send regular updates including inspection reports and market trends.
Reach out with solutions, not just problems.
Respond promptly, even when there’s nothing urgent.
Reactive Managers
Only contact you when something goes wrong.
Leave you wondering about the state of your property.
Respond slowly, especially outside business hours.
Ask yourself: When was the last time your manager reached out to you without needing to be chased?
Maintenance: Prevention or Patchwork?
Proactive Managers
Schedule routine inspections and maintenance regularly.
Have plans in place for seasonal upkeep.
Keep detailed logs of property conditions and future needs.
Reactive Managers
Only fix issues when tenants complain.
Lacks a visible maintenance schedule.
Rushed repairs often lead to subpar work.
Ever been blindsided by a hefty repair bill? That’s a huge red flag.
Tenant Selection: Careful or Careless?
Proactive Managers
Employ rigorous screening methods, including references and employment checks.
Clearly communicate expectations to tenants from day one.
Provide detailed entry condition reports complete with photos.
Reactive Managers
Rush to fill vacancies, often without proper screening.
Entry reports are vague or completely missing.
Tenant issues are only addressed upon their departure.
Are you curious why your property has had three different tenants in just a year?
Legislative & Compliance: Up-to-Date or Playing Catch-Up?
Proactive Managers
Stay current on local laws, including compliance with smoke alarms and safety switches.
Alert you of upcoming legal changes well in advance.
Arrange compliance checks proactively.
Reactive Managers
Only mention laws when there’s a problem.
Miss significant deadlines, leading to possible legal issues.
Leave you open to fines or repercussions.
Ignorance isn’t bliss—it’s costly.
Financial Reporting: Clear or Confusing?
Proactive Managers
Provide timely, detailed financial statements.
Alert you to any anomalies, whether related to late rent or unexpected expenses.
Assist in budgeting for future needs.
Reactive Managers
Reports arrive late or are often missing altogether.
You must dig to figure out any issues.
Surprises in your end-of-year summaries are common.
If you’re confused about missing rent, something isn’t right.
Market Insight: Stay Ahead or Stuck in the Past?
Proactive Managers
Consistently review pricing and market conditions.
Provide advice on how to maximise returns.
Identify opportunities for refinancing or portfolio growth.
Reactive Managers
Adjust rent only when you ask.
Provide no strategic insights.
Miss chances for increased income.
Is your rent behind the competition?
How to Tell: 10 Questions to Ask
If you’re uncertain whether your property manager is proactive or not, try asking these questions:
How often do you conduct routine inspections?
Can I see a copy of your maintenance schedule?
What is your tenant screening process?
How do you keep me informed about my property?
What’s your approach to handling urgent repairs?
How do you stay up-to-date with legislation changes?
Can you provide a sample financial statement?
How do you determine and review rent prices?
Do you have emergency contacts for after-hours issues?
10. What happens if a tenant falls behind on rent?
If they struggle or avoid answering these questions, you likely have a reactive manager.
Real-Life Example: Proactive vs Reactive In Action
Scenario A: Proactive Management
Imagine receiving an email that says: “During our quarterly inspection, we spotted a small leak under the kitchen sink. We’ve scheduled a plumber for tomorrow. The smoke alarms need testing next month, and that’s also on the agenda.”
No drama. No water damage. No frantic calls at midnight.
Scenario B: Reactive Management
Now picture this: You get a 10 PM call from a stressed tenant: “The kitchen is flooding!” The leak has been there for weeks, and now you’re dealing with emergency plumbing costs, along with needing new cabinetry. And the smoke alarms? They haven’t been checked in years.
Which scenario would you prefer?
The Hidden Costs of Reactive Property Management
You might think you’re saving on fees with a reactive manager, but consider these potential costs:
Emergency repairs are typically more expensive than routine maintenance.
High tenant turnover occurs when unhappy tenants leave, leading to vacancies and letting fees.
Property damage stems from ignored maintenance issues that worsen over time.
Legal troubles can arise from compliance oversights leading to fines.
Stress caused by constant emergencies—need we say more?
How to Switch to a Proactive Property Manager
If your current manager leans more towards “reactive,” it’s not too late to change. Here’s what to do:
Check your agreement: Know your notice period and exit clauses.
Find a replacement: Do thorough research—seek managers who excel in proactivity.
Communicate clearly: Inform your current manager that you’re switching and why.
Hand over documentation: Ensure all keys, records, and crucial details are transferred.
Monitor the transition: Stay involved until you're confident in the capabilities of your new manager.
Pro Tip: A genuinely proactive manager will facilitate an easy and seamless transition for you!
FAQs: Is Your Property Manager Proactive or Reactive? How to Tell
Q: How can I tell if my property manager is proactive?
A: Look for consistent communication, routine updates, scheduled maintenance checks, and how they manage legal compliance. Proactive managers are always a step ahead.
Q: Do proactive property managers charge higher fees?
A: Not necessarily. Though some may charge more, the savings from avoiding disasters and better property care often outweigh any extra costs.
Q: What is the biggest risk of having a reactive property manager?
A: The primary concerns include unexpected costs, tenant dissatisfaction, potential legal breaches, and a decline in your property's value.
Q: How often should a proactive property manager inspect my property?
A: Typically, proactively managed properties are inspected at least every three to four months, accompanied by detailed reports and suggested upkeep.
Q: Can a reactive manager become proactive?
A: Sometimes they can change, but usually, habits are hard to break. If you have to request basic services, it may be time to explore your options.
In conclusion, understanding whether your property manager is proactive or reactive isn’t just some theoretical exercise—it’s critical. Recognising the signs and asking the right questions can save you money, time, and significant headaches.
Don’t settle for “good enough.” Your investment—and your peace of mind—deserve better. Take a closer look, ask the tough questions, and if your manager isn't meeting expectations, remember: there are plenty of experts out there who will treat your property as their own.
Are you ready for a smoother, more profitable property journey? Now you know exactly what to look for!
Comments